RSS
 

Posts Tagged ‘America’

Steubenville: Another Window into the Soul of American Justice

20 Mar

Each high-profile court case in America provides a stage for the media and public to act out their stance on justice. This time, the noteworthy performances were the cheers on Twitter and the angry reaction from many toward CNN’s own reaction to the verdict.

Knowing the outline of the case, there seemed little doubt that these guys were guilty. I think most people watching felt the same. But when the verdict was announced, I saw no reason to cheer.

A lot of people did, though. And they did for two reasons: 1. punishment is necessary in America for the righteous to be vindicated. 2. Many attached this case to other social issues such as athletes not being above the law and women’s rights.

People and media revealed the extent of this attachment by cheering the punishment and by refusing any empathy for the perpetrators. In fact, those who did were attacked.

CNN’s journalists expressed considerable, honest concern for the boys after the reporter on the scene was moved by the tears and sorrow from the perpetrators. But doing so kicked a hornet’s nest all the way from the New Yorker to Jezebel to Gawker to the Huffington Post to Slate.

I watched the footage of CNN’s coverage on yet another site that was lambasting it. I watched it expecting the hosts to fawn over these guys in some melo-dramatic soap-opera-ish fashion.  But all it was, was two women showing concern. How could you not? The boy’s formerly-jailed father announced his failure as a dad and for the first time said to his son that he loved him. This same boy broke down in court when apologizing.

But there’s little room for this when such gripping issues are seen to be in the balance. And when justice got it right, the Tweets took off:

“Too much sympathy in court being shown for these disgusting little rapists. It is not a tragedy when a rapist is found guilty.#Steubenville

“When I was in college guys used to joke ‘passed out equals consent’ and it made my stomach turn. So glad for the Steubenville verdict.”

“There are a lot of tears in the courtroom. Wonder where the tears were for the victim that night? #Steubenville

“CONGRATULATIONS, JANE DOE! Justice in Steubenville is in your favor! Next stop: civil court!”

“Solidarity w/ Jane Doe. Happy for verdict, but it doesn’t stop today. She has to live with this when media coverage stops. #steubenville

“Don’t feel sorry rapists: Stop airing the men crying. Those were adult actions, they should’ve been tried as adults.”

“‘Those poor boys’ lives are ruined!’ — exactly what you should not be thinking after the#steubenville guilty verdict.”

All this hate toward these two guys–all the intolerance for any concern for them–is fear concerning America’s past of seeing jocks get away with crime and discrimination against women. This makes sympathy for the perpetrator translate into being in favor of letting athletes get away with whatever they want, and is seen a fight against women’s rights.

Some might say I just don’t fully appreciate the long and arduous uphill climb for equal rights. But I don’t think that appreciation for justice means taking pleasure in another’s harm. And I know in my heart that it’s the admirable thing to feel for even those who do bad things.  In this court case, though, that capacity has been shut off. It’s ironic that in a case where two boys violated a girl’s humanity, so many are out there to take away theirs.

 

to new plateaus,

-Brandon

 

 
 

Women in Underwear: American Style

03 Aug

Images are constantly used to make a statement. Sometimes, however, there’s more than one statement being made–and that’s the case below.

And instead of offering just one take, let’s encompass the multiple ways this picture can be seen.

 

 

What’s your initial reaction?

Mine was that the image is both a slight against rail-thin super models and a statement saying that women can be thicker and proud of how they look. (Included in this reaction was the surprise of just how skinny those top girls are when compared to the bottom ones.)

But then crept in an interruption to that sentiment. I looked at the heading about the bottom women: Real Beauty. It then seemed to be saying that it’s not just acceptable to be bigger, but something to be proud of. It had me wondering if this campaign wasn’t from Dove chocolate rather than Dove soap.

The third takeaway was offered by friend, Natalie. She found the whole conversation odd because no matter whose side your on in this “contest” you’re on the losing side, because we shouldn’t be contesting who’s better. And she added that “real women don’t have to strip down to their underwear.”

Either way you look at it, it offers a nice exercise in how one image can trigger different reactions. On Facebook, commentors range from the “you go girls!” to the “look at those sickly, skinny models” to the “why are we proud of being fat?” And yet, from all this, I did have an over-arching reaction encompassing these various responses: How American

How American it is to combine elements of women’s desire to be skinny, others’ plus-sizedness, celebrating being bigger, and pitting the two against each other in a half-naked contest.

 

 

 
 

Book Alert! (and new, old article)

08 Dec

Some of you have been awesome and followed me around China for as long as I’ve been blogging here on Area Voices. Others of you are also awesome and enjoying some of my older pieces in black and white in the Sunday editions of The Pioneer.

I’m excited to say that I’m taking all 70 of the articles I wrote about my experiences in Asia and compiling them into a book.

It’s more than simply taking all the pieces and putting them in one place. This book uses the best of the pieces to create chapters based on themes that kept hitting me over the head while I lived abroad.

Big topics, like:

Education
Nature and Man
Eastern Culture vs. Western Culture
Relationships and sex
and others

What struck me more than once was how being in a new environment teases out these life-lessons, even though I had been in similar environments before. For example, I grew up in a small town, but the freshness of a small town IN CHINA provided new insights into the big benefits of these small packaged communities.

I also grew up in the woods, but reveling in the nature of Asia helped me see the power behind our connection with the outdoors.

Dating women, teaching students, giving money to the poor.

I did all this stuff in America, but doing it abroad was doing it again for the first time.

And as such, this book will provide a rich look at life as it was presented to me (and as I was able to perceive it) living in China.

Every one of the themes bring us all closer together as a people, and so I name the book, as I named this blog.

“New Plateaus in China”

Indeed I did attain such heights, and it’s my hope that you can, too.

The book will be complete later this winter. I’m seeking support through the website, Kickstarter.com. I’ll fill you in on the specific website address when the proposal is posted for all to see.

“New Plateaus in China” will be both an eBook and a paper book. The eBook, though, will leverage its capabilities with more pictures, links to other content, and feedback mechanisms built-in.

So I’ll keep ya’ll posted on the progress of it. :)

In the meantime, here’s one of the articles that none of you have read, because I wrote it for my old blog. It’s about an insight/experience I had about the American and Chinese educations systems.

Enjoy and to “New Plateaus in China”,

-Brandon

APPLES TO APPLES TO ORANGES

My school offers a monthly event called “English Club.” It’s an opportunity for community members to attend an hour-and–a–half free, discussion-based class with one of our staff. It’s a nice way for my school to reach out, and a nice way for area folks to come test their English.

As teachers, we’re asked to address something light, yet talk-provoking. Last weekend I was the teacher and chose to talk about summer event and activities. It was low-key stuff with swimming, relaxing, and travelling all being mentioned. But half of the attendees were high-school aged, and some interesting things came up about their schooling.

I found out that the older the students get, the less time off they have in the summer. For a 12-year-old present it was two months. For the 16-year-old it was less than a month! She could even remember the dates.

“Last year is was July 14th to August 5th”, she said.

I wondered if the school days in June and July were half-time or less. But though the school subjects apparently change during the summer months, the day’s length was no different. In all, breaks are sprinkled throughout the year with two longer ones in summer and winter. In other words, school is much like a career to the 16 to 18-year-olds. They go to school about 80 more days a year than U.S. students. For subjects, they choose a track of either math or literature after a foundation of basics.

It’s tempting to compare apples to apples. Figures like these cause concern about the degree to which American students might be out-paced. Indeed, it is a concern for the U.S. students who heavily rely on more time spent in school. This logic may promote calls to expand the school year, etc. And this would be valid.

But I also happen to be working on an article on “Ways to stay sharp during the summer holiday”. And in doing so, I soon realized that the lessons that can be learned away from school are actually the most important ones. It’s a time to flex one’s initiative: travel, exploration, research, projects, experimentation, getting a job, volunteering, organizing. What I came up with was a list that really promotes growth and accomplishment.

I also realized that America has benefited (and been defined) by these endeavors of motivated individuals. Those that see the apples to apples likely see public school exposure to be THE determiner of a child’s success. I think America has gotten a little stuck in this theme, and frankly, America will have a tough time competing when it comes to regimented public activity. It didn’t grow up that way.

So let’s not forget that there’s more than one script, and the different scripts of China and America also make this comparison apples and oranges. Heck, looking at it this way: one could also say that China’s kids are stuck in school for a long time, unable to be themselves!

In fact, this point was brought up by one 15-year-old girl at the English Club. She recognized that the China system is strong and is pumping out educated kids in remarkable numbers. But it’s also producing few leaders and creative people. The opposite is the trade-off that America has always and indefinitely will face: less impressive nation-wide efforts—school, health care—but continue to create ways to change the world.

The trade-offs for both countries, evident in their education systems, makes perfect sense given the path they’re on and their strengths exhibited.

 
 

Feminine Power

19 Oct

Greetings Readers,

An article of mine about China was featured on the website: The Good Men Project. I want to share it with you. :)

I will say, though, that it’s a bit different than the travelogueing you are used to. In the spirit of “reaching new plateaus”, I sometimes delve into deeper themes of humanity. Here, I talk about the idea of feminine power: how I became introduced to it, how it was clearer to see in China, and how we lack its understanding in America.

Enjoy!

http://goodmenproject.com/featured-content/feminine-power-the-recognition/